Pop culture has taught us to view rape as something that occurs in dark alleyways, during out of control parties, or at knifepoint. We traditionally think of rapists as psychotic rather than average men (and certainly not as our significant others). While rape certain occurs in the remarkable fashion that is most commonly presented, these instances are the exception and not the rule—rape encompasses much more than we often imagine. Susan Brownmiller writes that rape “is nothing more or less than a conscious process of intimidation by which all men keep all women in a state of fear” (Schneir 272) and that “the typical American perpetrator of forcible rape is little more than an aggressive, hostile youth who chooses to do violence to women” (274).
When we begin to recognize that rape is not some rare phenomenon, we begin to realize how often it really does happen. Emilie Morgan writes of the THREE different times she was raped. The second time she was raped, she explains, occurred on a date. She describes, “he didn’t overpower me like the man who had raped me three years earlier. He simply didn’t stop when I told him to” (Findlen 36). Society has not always taught us that this is rape, but according to the Boston Area Rape Crisis Center, a national study reported that 75% of all rape survivors know their attackers. Simply because the act is not consensual, it most certainly is sexual assault in the form of rape. However, our (patriarchal) society has encouraged us to downplay these events. We are told we did not speak up for ourselves loudly enough, it was just a misunderstanding, our significant other didn’t mean to hurt us. The experience of women is thus delegitimized.
Worse, women are even blamed for their own rape. After discussing the self-confidence and self-assuredness that learning self-defense gave her, Whitney Walker writes, “And then there’s the double standard that comes from the same sources that advise against self-defense. If you get raped, the first question is “Did you fight back?” “No.” You must have wanted it.” No other crime victims are accused of encouraging the attack… the male robbery victim does not get blamed for keeping his wallet in his back pocket” (Findlen 131). Women who dress, flirt, or otherwise act sexually or suggestively supposedly want to get raped—they asked for it. Some even go as far as to claim that the woman enjoyed herself. I can’t even fathom such a statement—being raped is an enjoyable experience??
This culture revolving around sex (and thus to a certain degree, rape) is affecting today’s youth. Younger generations of girls are being taught that they need to submit to sex and the desires of men. Says Ariel Levy, “about a quarter of girls between ages fifteen and nineteen describe their first time as “voluntary but unwanted” according to the Henry J. Kaiser Family Foundation. The only message that seems to be successfully transmitted to girls about sex and sexiness is that it is something they need to embody to be cool” (Levy 163). The pressure and examples set by the greater society are thus taking away women’s choice and control over their own actions and decisions. In regards to this, Whitney Walker asks, “Why is a woman’s right to control her body constantly threatened? Whether referring to reproductive rights or sexual violence, the answer is to take control back” (Findlen 131). For Walker, the way to do so was self-defense, but there are certainly other ways to combat a culture of rape. Solidarity between women and sharing of experiences can promote healing, and efforts like “Take Back the Night” can help promote awareness. Most importantly, we first need to acknowledge the many ways in which rape (and other forms of sexual assault) happens. Once we recognize the experience of women, we can begin to “take back control” and change it.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Rape happens a lot more often than we all think, or at least more than we are taught. Susan Brownmiller writes, “She saw rape as an ‘exercise in power’ that perpetuates male domination of women; she deflated the myth of the glamorous, virile ‘heroic rapist’; and she refuted certain ‘deadly myths of rape’—such as ‘all women want to raped,’ ‘She was asking for it’ and ‘if you’re going to be raped, you might as well as relax and enjoy it’ (272).” It’s absurd that someone would actually think that all women want to be raped. It’s ridiculous; no one wants to be forced to have sex with someone. Sex is supposed to be intimate, with someone special, a consensual act. Sex is not supposed to be about who has the power and control in the relationship. And, often times when a women does get raped she is taught to keep quiet about it.
ReplyDeleteMeghan writes, “Women who dress, flirt, or otherwise act sexually suggestively supposedly want to get raped—they asked for it. Some even go as far as to claim that the woman enjoyed herself. I can’t even fathom such a statement—being raped is an enjoyable experience??“ The fact that anyone would think that someone wants to get raped is frankly disturbing. No one wants to be forced to have sex with someone, people don’t go out on a Saturday night and say, “I can’t wait to get raped tonight.” Being raped is one of the most awful things that can happen to someone, and it’s mind blowing that someone would actually think that a woman wants to be raped.
Sex is such a huge part of today’s culture and girls are beginning to have sex earlier and earlier. Society is making it seem that sex is all that men want, and if women don’t give it to them, then they don’t mean anything at all. Sex is the thing to do these days, at least that’s what we’re taught by the media. Girls need to know that sex is not the most important thing in life, and that they should not succumb to society and have sex with a man if they do not want to. Meghan writes, “Most importantly, we first need to acknowledge the many ways in which rape (and other forms of sexual assault) happens. Once we recognize the experience of women, we can begin to ‘take back control’ and change it.” Meghan is absolutely right, we must recognize rape and how serious it is, and only then can we start to make a change. We should not be downplaying rape; rape is a serious issue and it needs to be treated like one.
This issue is something that has recently come to my attention because of the CCLS and Angelica's speech at the chapel last semester. The most shocking part of it all is how often rape and sexual harrassment/assault actually occurs, and how seemingly innocent the situations can be. Meghan is right...we see rape as happening in dark corners by crazy men, when in reality, it may be in a dorm room by your own boyfriend. Morgan describes in her article how she had "basically come to terms with what had happened and considered it a part of growing up" (35). Rape is NOT a part of growing up; it is a completely skewed way to view both sex and male/female relationships. Women are never to blame for being raped.
ReplyDeleteWalker discusses the importance of self defense. She says, "Equal rights means women should be equal to (not the same as, but equal to) men in all ways-including equal fighters' (129). The importance of learning to defend ourselves is not so much for the purpose of kicking every guys ass that looks at us the wrong way, but knowing that we COULD. Confidence in our ability to fight back means confidence in ourselves as a whole...and I think that is underestimated; people who are confident in themselves give off a certain kind of toughness that men are less likely to mess with...and that is what women need to start working towards to let men know that rape is NOT an option. Ever.
Levy discusses the idea that young girls are taught to be sexy without really knowing the meaning of the word. Nonetheless, the need for men to see them as hot is a driving force for girls that seem far too young...and it completely skews the way these women are growing to view sexual relationships with men. This goes back to our talk about educating younger girls and boys about sex, and not viewing it as such a taboo topic. Girls need to learn that sex is not about being sexy, but about experiencing true sexuality, and they will never find that through mini skirts and tube tops.
Perhaps Brownmiller was being intentionally controversial when she famously declared that “rape is nothing more or less than a conscious process of intimidation by which all men keep all women in a state of fear” (p. 272); understandably, this remark has often proved to be incendiary. It implicates the male gender in an act that most would condemn and furthermore suggests that it is a conscious tactic.
ReplyDeleteHowever, I think the point Brownmiller is trying to make is not that every man is a rapist, but rather that we live in a culture where the fear of rape is pervasive. Although every man is certainly not a rapist and most will never commit the crime, as men they still hold the position of a potential rapist and therefore are a source of fear. The pivotal question is not whether a man WILL rape a woman, but whether he could. And in a culture where women are constantly told that they are the weaker sex, where submission is expected and where we are told, as Walker notes that fighting back is useless, women are constantly coerced into seeing themselves as a victim in a world where any man at any moment has the advantage over her.
Furthermore, as Brownmiller points out, there is no such thing as a typical rapist; rapists cannot be easily be separated from other men because the men who commit rape generally share the same profile as those who commit any other violent crime: namely young men of lower economic standing. As such, the same violent subculture that propagates burglaries and assaults propagates rapes. In particular, Brownmiller cites the machismo factor, of which, along with demonstrations of masculinity and toughness, sexual aggression is a key characteristic. Brownmiller posits that our understanding of rape, therefore, must shift from seeing it as an act of lust or an inherently sexual crime to seeing it as a systematic enactment of masculine domination in a violent crime that is carried out in a sexual way.
The disturbing prevalence of rape begs the question: in what kind of society does rape become a systematic phenomenon? Turning to Levy’s discussion of sex among teenagers and young adults—teenage males aged 15 to 19 are the demographic most likely to commit rape—it becomes clear that sexual coercion is the norm. For example, Levy cites a study in which 25% of women who lose their virginity as teenagers describe the experience as “voluntary but unwanted” and one of the girls whom Levy interviews admits that she had sex before she wanted to out of fear of her boyfriend breaking up with her. While being talked into having sex is not rape insofar as consent was granted, it suggests that women can be coerced into having sex and perpetuates notions of female sexual submission.
Again turning to Walker’s article, there is a sense that women should give in to men because resistance might escalate an already tenuous situation. As such, issuing consent when sex is in fact unwanted is just another means of sexual coercion: the possibility exists that in some cases consent is given out of fear of a situation escalating to rape. I think this possibility illustrates Brownmiller’s earlier statement in that, even if no rape actually occurs, the possibility of rape and the culture in which rape is a constant threat influences the way we as women act.
I think you all make valid points about the rape culture. I actually found that hard to type..."rape culture". But, as so many of you all pointed out, it does exist. As pointed out by Meghanin her blog, women often know their attakers, like the the instance in which Emile Morgan writes about telling her partner to stop, yet he continued. Before, I came to Colgate, was relatively unaware and uneducated about the rape culture. However, I think....know that the rape culture is present of campus although few are willing to admit this. I think its great that we are able to discuss this and bring it to the open because imagine the awareness that we are now placed into. Also, although I know this is a women studies class, I think we shall say that rape affects everyone. Women are not just he victims, but men and children as well. The rape culture as silenced men because men are supposed to be strong...it's impossible for them to get raped. Yet, the reality is that it happens. No one is safe from it.
ReplyDelete